The Future of Autonomous Defense
On 13 October 2026, HavocAI hosted a reception at the Washington Post to show its latest generation of autonomous boats, drones and vehicles. The company’s pitch is a software one, a single operator should be able to task and supervise tens, hundreds or thousands of autonomous assets across the globe.
Making the case was Paul Lwin, HavocAI’s co-founder and chief executive, and a former Navy test pilot and electronic warfare officer who flew combat missions over Afghanistan and Iraq. His argument was that the United States spends too much money on defense rather than making economically sustainable technology that could have similar results.
A Trade You Lose Even When You Win
Lwin’s framing was that the USA spends trillions of dollars on defense but still cannot reliably buy an iPad easily. The Pentagon cannot buy that type of item efficiently because the acquisition system was not built to buy cheap commercial technology.
This surely matters as the arithmetic of modern conflict has changed. It is the cost-exchange ratio which causes the USA million dollars losses. The US employs an expensive interceptor to target a thousand-dollar drone. Repeat it a few thousand times and the exchange becomes strategically decisive. An adversary who can generate cheap mass weapons does not need to match the USA’s capability, it only needs to make American capability too expensive.
The Ukrainian government and people have already demonstrated that even a force with almost no traditional navy can challenge a much larger one using inexpensive equipment. They began the war with no navy but still managed to inflict serious damage on Russia’s Black Sea Fleet, sinking and disabling vessels with small boats that cost about as much as a car and drones built with parts ordered from Amazon. This can create serious problems for a powerful navy.
Lwin explained that Iran uses a similar strategy in the Strait of Hormuz, where small boats, sea mines, and anti-ship missiles can threaten ships. Protecting these shipping routes with traditional naval forces would be very expensive for the USA. In both cases, the advantage of asymmetric naval power lies in its low cost of deployment versus the high cost of defense.
Government’s Involvement with Private Sector
Lwin highlighted how recent government contracts have made it easier for smaller, less traditional companies to work with the Pentagon. They have made it easier for small contractors to receive timely payments, and to show investors they are generating revenue. This is important because being paid reliably helps companies attract investment and continue developing their products. He argued that these changes benefit the entire industry, not just HavocAI.
He also suggested that the Pentagon is genuinely trying to build a new relationship with private companies. The success of this shift will depend on whether new companies entering the defense market can benefit from these changes in practice.
My Takeaway
The event concluded with a demonstration of remotely controlling automated boats at sea using a handheld controller. This was a powerful illustration of how technology is changing naval warfare, surveillance, and maritime security. However, it also raised important questions for me about ethical boundaries and accountability. When such powerful technology can be controlled by a single individual, who would be responsible for the decisions made and the consequences that follow. I am also concerned about the cybersecurity risks associated with these systems. Given that these boats are relatively inexpensive and mass-produced, risk of vulnerabilities could rise in terms of cyberattacks, hacking, or unauthorized control. While these innovations offer significant strategic advantages in the economic sense, their ethical and security implications deserve equal attention.