Skip to main content

Consumer Confidence Is Cracking at the Top — and That’s a Warning for Investors

For much of the past two years, U.S. economic growth has rested on an uncomfortable truth: it has been carried disproportionately by high-income households. While inflation, housing costs, and credit tightening constrained most consumers, those earning over $100,000 continued to spend—and in doing so, propped up GDP growth.

That support is now wavering.


According to the January 2026 Macro Update from Morning Consult, consumer confidence among high-income earners has fallen sharply and unusually fast, prompting a downgrade of sentiment risk for this group from Medium to High . Over just 16 days, the Index of Consumer Sentiment (ICS) for households earning more than $100,000 declined by 17.4 points, a 12.3% drop in only 30 days—one of the steepest declines in the series’ history.

For impact investors, this is not a curiosity. It is a leading indicator.


The Consumer-Led Growth Model Is Showing Its Limits

Morning Consult’s data make clear why this shift matters. In 2025, nearly all real spending growth came from high-income consumers, while spending by lower- and middle-income households stagnated or declined in real terms .

This dynamic masked structural weaknesses:

  • Rising economic precarity below the top income tier

  • Limited wage growth relative to costs for most workers

  • Heavy reliance on asset-rich households to sustain demand

Impact investors have long warned that growth concentrated at the top is not resilient growth. When confidence erodes among those households, the broader economy loses its final buffer.


This Time Is Different—and That’s the Risk

Historically, sharp declines in high-income confidence have coincided with equity market selloffs—during the 2018 market correction, the onset of COVID-19, and the 2022 inflation shock. But Morning Consult highlights a crucial distinction: the current collapse in sentiment is not being driven by stock market losses .

Instead, the decline is broad-based across all five components of sentiment:

  • Expectations for personal finances

  • Perceptions of current business conditions

  • Outlook for future economic growth

  • Willingness to make major purchases

This suggests a deeper reassessment of economic security, not just portfolio values.


Labor Market Anxiety Has Reached the Professional Class

One of the most consequential findings in the report is the rise in pay-loss expectations among high-income workers. Even as headline employment remains relatively stable, a growing share of professionals expect to lose income in the near term .

This reflects a structural shift that impact investors should take seriously:

  • AI and automation are reshaping white-collar labor markets

  • Income volatility is spreading up the earnings distribution

  • Job insecurity is no longer confined to low-wage sectors

Confidence is falling not because households are already experiencing hardship, but because they increasingly believe their insulation from risk is gone.


Inflation Expectations Are Re-Anchoring—Upward

Compounding these anxieties, Morning Consult shows that inflation expectations rose in December, even as gasoline prices declined . This divergence signals skepticism that price stability has truly been restored.

For impact-oriented capital, this matters because persistent inflation expectations disproportionately harm:

  • Renters

  • Workers without pricing power

  • Small and minority-owned businesses

When higher-income households lose confidence, they pull back. When inflation expectations remain elevated, lower-income households fall further behind. Together, these forces widen inequality and suppress sustainable demand.


Consumer Health Is Already Deteriorating

The report shows that declines in high-income sentiment have already translated into a sharp deterioration in the Consumer Health Index for that group, dragging down overall consumer health readings across the economy .

Once high-income consumers shift from spending to precautionary saving, the effects cascade:

  • Reduced discretionary spending

  • Slower small-business revenue growth

  • Higher risk for service-sector employment

For impact investors focused on community resilience, this is where macro signals become local realities.


What This Means for Impact Investing in 2026

This data does not guarantee a recession. Past episodes show that sentiment can stabilize without a full economic contraction. But it does underscore three lessons central to impact investing:

  1. Growth concentrated at the top is fragile

  2. Confidence is as important as income in sustaining demand

  3. Labor-market insecurity is now a system-wide risk, not a niche issue

The takeaway is clear: sustainable economic growth cannot rely on a narrow slice of households to carry consumption while the majority tread water. Impact investing strategies that strengthen wage growth, job security, affordable housing, and access to capital are no longer just socially desirable—they are macroeconomically necessary.

When even the highest earners begin to pull back, the economy is signaling that underlying imbalances have gone unresolved for too long.


Source: Morning Consult, “January 2026 Macro Update: Confidence is Plunging Among High-Income Earners,” January 13, 2026.

Popular posts from this blog

Kamalanomics: Home and Health

Vice President Kamala Harris recently unveiled her economic plan, which builds upon and expands several initiatives from the Biden administration while adding new elements aimed at addressing economic challenges faced by American families. Her plan, dubbed the "Opportunity Economy" agenda, focuses on lowering costs for essential goods and services, particularly targeting housing, healthcare, and groceries. Key Components: 1. Housing: Harris proposes constructing three million new homes to address the housing supply crunch, which is more ambitious than Biden's two-million-home plan. She also advocates for a $40 billion "innovation fund" to encourage local governments to find solutions to housing shortages and make it harder for investment companies to buy up large numbers of rental properties, which has driven up rent prices. (See: Comments to the CalPERS Board of Administration, July 15, 2024 on Housing and Environmental Investing.) 2. Healthcare: Expanding on B...

Maternal Health Financing Facility for Black Women: A Solution to an Urgent Problem

Maternal mortality is a significant issue in the United States, with Black women disproportionately affected. Research conducted by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) has shown that Black women are more likely to die from pregnancy-related causes than their white counterparts. However, the issue is not new, and despite the increasing amount of data available, the disparities have remained unaddressed for far too long.  Creative Investment Research (CIR) is among the organizations that believe there is a solution to the problem. Through our proposed impact investing vehicle , the Maternal Health Financing Facility for Black Women (MHFFBW), we aim to tackle the mortality gap and support Black women during childbirth, which will, in turn, benefit their communities. The Facility, based on legally binding financing agreements containing terms and conditions that direct resources to individuals and institutions capable of addressing supply-side conditions at the heart...

William Michael Cunningham on Impact Investing, Blockchain, and Crowdfunding

September 2018 - 10 Questions William Michael Cunningham on Impact Investing, Blockchain, and Crowdfunding Interview by Carly Schulaka WHO: William Michael Cunningham WHAT: Economist, impact investing specialist, founder of Creative Investment Research WHAT'S ON HIS MIND: “Any finance professional in the U.S. should learn how to create a blockchain.” 1. You are an economist, an inventor, and an impact investing specialist. I’ve heard you say: “True innovation happens in a way that is independent of monetary returns.” How does this statement influence your work? It’s really about finding an interesting problem and applying financial technology to solving that problem or to dealing with that problem. You know, the people who invented the alphabet didn’t do so to make money. They had an interesting problem—communication on both a local and a grand scale—and if you were to calculate the social return for the invention of that technology or technique, it’s almost infinit...